DISQUS

DISQUS Hello! GoodWordEditing.com is using DISQUS, a powerful comment system, to manage its comments. Learn more.

Community Page

GoodWordEditing.com

Editing, writing, faith, and work. And poetry because I like poetry.
Jump to original thread »
Author

How Well Read Are Acquisitions Editors?

Started by goodwordediting · 9 months ago

Not very to this little publicity stunt. Apparently, the Jane Austen Festival submitted three book proposals based on Jane Austen’s books, including sample chapters that were remarkably similar to the original manuscripts–even going so far as to state verbatim the first s ... Continue reading »

7 comments

  • L.L. Barkat

    1 year ago

    It shows the power of context, doesn't it? And that in itself is an interesting topic to consider.
    reply
  • Marcus

    1 year ago

    L.L., you are the master of the two sentence comment. Awesome.
    reply
  • Real Live Preacher

    1 year ago

    Well, that's always the situation with classics, isn't it? You have to go back into their worldview to enjoy them. And that's fun, but probably not something I want to do with everything I read. Our best stuff will one day be classic, and it probably won't fit either.
    reply
  • Every Square Inch

    1 year ago

    Rather than defend the acq. editors, I would hope that they and anyone in a position of critic or evaluator would be sobered and humbled.

    LL's point is also spot on...context - historical, cultural, circumstantial all matter in our evaluation.
    reply
  • Marcus

    1 year ago

    The thing about a classic is that it speaks to people in many different contexts, though. Right? Why is that so hard to market, though?
    reply
  • Eve

    1 year ago

    Probably because it used to speak to so many people, but no longer does.

    Why?
    I think because
    a)many no longer read them
    b)the language is difficult for many to wade through and
    c)there are so many new books out there that are enticing all of us.

    Just a thought, of course. :)
    reply
  • Marcus

    1 year ago

    So, Eve, are you suggesting that "classics" only sell well because the educational system has functioned as a marketing vehicle to force students to buy books they never read? : )

    I actually like some of them. Pride and Prejudice, for instance.
    reply

Add New Comment

Returning? Login