GoodWordEditing.com - Latest Comments in Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

RickD335 — Wed, 26 Nov 2008 20:59:55 -0000

Hi Marcus,

Actually, I think you probably expressed it rather well (and no, I wasn't going into the voting thing). Quiet sad thoughts about dying kids is a small suffering - enough of those and one of two things happen (to the average person), and neither of the choices are terribly appealing. One is to get depressed - clinically depressed - about our helplessness in the face of all the tragedy, while the other is grief fatigue, where we become inured to the suffering of others.

Or, you could be motivated into action to help alleviate the suffering of others - whether children, the homeless, any who qualify as the least of these - and on a local level, trusting God to work within the hearts of others in other locales or with deeper pockets. Even so, you are right - it is not the same as knowing and sharing in Christ's suffering.

Thanks for a great post - and topic!

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Wed, 26 Nov 2008 08:34:16 -0000

Of course, I'm overthinking this! That's part of the point. Seriously
though, this isn't about me, it's about trying to understand people who are
outside the lingo. Most of my best life long friends are not Christians.
They specifically don't understand phrases like "personal relationship."

My theory is that the metaphor has become a code for us. We have a lot of
codes in the church. A lot of secret handshakes. If you know the codes and
handshakes, you're in. If you don't, well...

Peter, funny you
mention "Pastor/priest/bishop/whatever-you-want-to-call-him-or-her."
There's a line in the play that is almost that verbatim. One character
says, "So now we're just back to the same old dumb church routine--follow
the pastor-preacher-priest whatever because I'm just a dumb sheep?"

Rick, I'm with you on suffering. The problem is that if I'm honest, there's
very little connection between suffering as I actually experience it and
see it, and the worldwide issues of suffering you describe. Seriously, what
can I do to help kids whose lives are cut short by war? I'm already careful
how I vote, if that's where you're going. But you see how far we are from
suffering already? I want to know Christ--and share in his suffering
somehow beyond just having quiet sad thoughts about dying kids. That sounds
pretty callous probably, but I'm looking for a personal relationship, not
abstraction.

Like everyone is saying, a lot of this comes down to disciplines--regular
study, regular prayer, regular conversations with other Christians (like
this).

Thanks everyone for being so open and honest and kind and generous with
your thoughts.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Peter P — Wed, 26 Nov 2008 04:01:05 -0000

Very interesting post. I have discussed Christian terminology many times with people but the phrase 'personal relationship with Jesus' has never before been brought up as a difficult one to me.

My take on it is this:

You can be in a church where you have a Pastor/priest/bishop/whatever-you-want-to-call-him-or-her and you are encouraged to speak to that (let's use the term priest) and they in turn will talk to God for you. Yes, I know, but it happens. I know of people who will talk to their priest or even pray to a saint but would never dream of even attempting to communicate directly with any member of the trinity.

On the other hand, you can recognize that Jesus Christ is interceding for us and came to earth to create a way for us to come into relationship with Him so you can walk the daily path of discovering what a personal relationship with an intimate God is.

God speaks to you in many ways, maybe not audibly but certainly not just through the bible and any relationship is about learning to communicate and then communicating in that way.

I think you're over-thinking this. You almost certainly have a personal relationship with Jesus, what's happening now is you're learning how to have a deeper relationship with Him.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

RickD335 — Tue, 25 Nov 2008 21:14:00 -0000

Marcus,

Some of that - to me, at least - is obvious. Do you not grieve for every story about a baby being born, then dumped into a trashcan like yesterday's leftovers? Or for the kids whose lives are cut short by war?

I named two real examples that have to cause God suffering - Christ saw it all from the cross (that's the one I still have a hard time wrapping my pea brain around) 2000+ years ago, and sees it today.

Just my .02; your mileage may vary...

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Tue, 25 Nov 2008 20:09:06 -0000

Thanks for all of the great comments everyone. After a weekend of exhaustion
and performance (with mixed results, but overall not bad), here's where I
landed.

A personal relationship is a metaphor--like every metaphor we find in the
Bible its imperfect.

David says God is a strong tower. Well, of course, that's only one aspect of
God. Talking about a personal relationship with God is an implied metaphor
that he is a very close friend or family member--but even that metaphor is
just an approximation.

So what does it mean to have a personal relationship? All I can do is say
with Paul, "I *want* to know Christ... and the power of his rising, sharing
in his suffering and conforming to his death. I'll pour out my life, to be
filled with the Spirit. Joy follows suffering and life follows death."

A personal relationship is when I share someone's suffering. A personal
relationship with God is when I share his suffering by pouring out my life
as he did.

That's where I'm at for now. If only I could figure out what it means to
share in God's suffering...

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

PoemiaDei — Tue, 25 Nov 2008 12:55:43 -0000

Christianity, as defined in the Bible, is a personal life with Christ. It is the Christ-life lived in us. It does not make sense to our natural or human mind-set because it was not meant to by God. However, like the other things of God, the Holy Spirit has a way of revealing them to us. And like Peter, a seasoned sea-man, venturing to walk on the waters and believing he could because Jesus told him to do so, we just believe what the Holy Spirit reveals and its reality to us from a completely new mindset. Funny indeed! But the Bible again forwarned us the things of God are foolishness to man. The plates are before us - God's wisdom or human wisdon. God will give us grace to accept His. So, indeed, the Christian life is a personal relationship with Jesus Christ. The Bible defines it so. To become a Christian is to be made a new creature IN CHRIST, to be bapized INTO CHRIST, and for CHRIST TO LIVE IN US. How much more personal can you get with someone? What more, it's a walk by faith not by sight.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Adelani Aderemi — Tue, 25 Nov 2008 11:21:58 -0000

I enjoyed this. I often think we are only called to lease out our hearts for the Spirit to live in, so HE can have that personal relationship with Christ as HE lives in our heart. The tenancy period will be long enough that we will find ourselves caught up in eternity and we will then receive the payment, which is eternal life. Apart from that, how really can mortal and definite beings have a personal relationship with an immortal and infinite Spirit?
Well, its just like Mark to provoke this kind of debate. I enjoy it.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

RickD335 — Mon, 24 Nov 2008 21:30:09 -0000

Coming to faith in Christ via the particular path I did, I always cringed at the phrases that got tossed around (still do, in some quarters) - "Have YOU been saved? Do YOU know Jesus as your personal Lord and Saviour?" Those two, especially when strung together like that, strike me as the worst possible way to attract someone's attention.

The relationship I have with God today is a far cry from what it once was, just as the life I've been given back to live anew is a far cry from what it once was. Childhood? Indoctrination to Catholicism via the guilt and shame model. Adolescence? I could almost feel God's presence telling me something was wrong in what I understood about Him - but instead of drawing closer, asking questions, reading Scripture, I found another way to deal - addiction.

In adulthood (late 20's), I was reaching the end of my rope and the end of my life was in view (in my eyes as well as those of others). Without going into all the details, I found my way to AA. After being in that fellowship for around three months or so, there was a young man who was always telling me in a teasing manner, "Rick - Jesus loves you!", knowing that I would react with anger and obscenity. I didn't want to hear about Jesus... but at the same time, I had to admit to myself that I'd never once really considered who He was, any of the claims He'd made, and what any of that might mean to me. Over the course of the next few months, the more work I put into working the Steps, I realized that God (as I didn't understand Him) was doing something for me that I could not possibly have done on my own, and that perhaps it was time I learned more about Him. A friend offered me a copy of "Mere Christianity." I read it slowly, treasuring what I was reading. I picked up a Bible, started out asking other believers in the fellowship what it was like for them, this new life I was beginning to experience.

Fast forward to today. If you want to know what I believe, watch what I do, listen to what I say. Will I stumble? Yep. Will I fall? Likely. Will I ever forget again who loves me, saved me from myself, and has work for me to do? Not likely. I'll not use the phrase "have a personal relationship" - if my life isn't reflecting the relationship I'm in, then it's a hollow phrase. I don't have to have all the answers today - if God wants to use me to speak into someone's life, I'm here. Thanks for being here - y'all are family today, and that is an important relationship that can be seen.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

dukeslee — Sun, 23 Nov 2008 23:42:41 -0000

My seven-year-old and I had a conversation about this today while visiting another church. She saw a sign that said 'Seek, and you will find.' She says to me, "I keep looking but I don't see Him, Mom. Why is that?" I explained to her that God really is there, and that we can trust that He really is there, if we can't see Him or hear Him talking back to us. ... I think we cheapen this Thing we have with God, when we boil it down to a "personal relationship." As if you can define this mystery by using terms created expressly for human relationships. God is so much bigger than any of it. He's not a "boyfriend" with whom we have a "personal relationship." He's God.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Real Live Preacher — Sun, 23 Nov 2008 20:25:07 -0000

I love your honesty. I always try to remember that the easiest cover for having no relationship with God and no idea how to have one is to claim a personal relationship with Jesus Christ and then stand there looking smug. "I said it. I called it. So I have it. So leave me along."

I'd much rather talk to someone who has a sense of the Holiness of God and is rightly afraid and uncertain.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

karla — Sun, 23 Nov 2008 17:58:14 -0000

Yeah, I've never personally been able to make myself use that expression, "personal relationship with God." Intuitively, I "know" (believe/hope) with all that is in me that God is there, that he listens to me, and that sometimes he "does something" inside me that moves me to act in a certain way, or "strangely warms" me inside that I "know" (believe/hope) to be the movings of the holy, the Spirit, that I take to be "communications" to me. But personal? Well, only in the concocted definition of person we've come up with via our trinitarian attempt to make a model for wrapping our minds around the fullness and incomprehensible mystery that is God. I hope that doesn't sound irreverent, but we're all being honest here, it sounds like. It's just that, for me at least, I can't claim any immediacy of satisfying two-way dialogue like would be expected/assumed for any other personal relationship I've had. Whatever it is that occurs between God and his creatures, personal relationship fails to adequately describe it. Of course, most any words we would choose would fall short, so I guess we return to where we started, don't we, at a loss for adequate words, though no shortage of attempted ones, eh? :)

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Sam Van Eman — Fri, 21 Nov 2008 11:16:55 -0000

Thanks for Dave's blog link. His new book title made me laugh and I had to go see what else he has to say.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Fri, 21 Nov 2008 11:02:21 -0000

Funny that you mention that verse, Blake. Here's where I've landed for now.
A personal relationship with Jesus means this, "I want to know Christ and
the power of his rising, share in his suffering and conform to his death."
My personal relationship begins when I share in his sufferings... whatever
that means. : )

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

blake — Fri, 21 Nov 2008 08:44:39 -0000

"Having a personal relationship with God." Yeh, I often feel guilt (good Baptist boy that I am) over that metaphor. I can "measure" the growth in my relationships with people, but it's not that simple with God. It's a little distressing. But one good thing about the metaphor: it pushes me to not just know ABOUT God, but to know God better. It's what Paul says in Phil. 3: "to know Christ and the power of His resurrection..." Still trying to figure it all out...

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Fri, 21 Nov 2008 08:36:12 -0000

The cipher book would be for us, not others. We can't expect to help people
if we require them to learn our language first. Instead, we have to learn
THEIR language. In the US this can be particularly tricky because so many
people claim Christianity. It seems like we're always starting with damage
control.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

David — Fri, 21 Nov 2008 03:00:29 -0000

M--

Your comment on language really struck me. Its almost like we speak in code, a secret language no one else understands. Then, when we present the gospel, we don't know how to do it in real-talk. WE almost need to hand them a cipher book!

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 22:36:19 -0000

So true, Melissa. Good to hear from you again. There's another line in the
play where someone says, "I don't know how to have a relationship with a
ghost." It's tricky, you know? We use this language to make God real, but it
sometimes it works against us.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Melissa — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 20:46:21 -0000

You asked "what does it mean to relate to God?" which I've been struggling with, in a different way. I recently wrote to myself during church right after musical worship "What does it mean to LOVE God, and how can I love a God I don't fully understand?" and it relates to your question of what a personal relationship with Jesus is. and many many many other "churchy" words. I think "personal relationship with Jesus" is a weird expression... to get personal with Jesus, you're also personal with God, and that's all through the Holy Spirit. That's who is in the coffeeshop with you listening and talking back. If you sit down to "spend time with the Lord" you can ask the Holy Spirit to be with you, because He's already inside waiting for it. And that's the only way to understand a tiny bit of God, and Jesus, and understanding them really helps to figure out how to love God and relate to God.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 15:51:30 -0000

Sounds like a good plan for next week.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

Papa Poet — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 15:46:47 -0000

I prescribe 1 hour, coffee, and N.T. Wright's Surprised By Hope.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

goodwordediting — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 14:31:26 -0000

Funny that you mention God being "big enough." Someone else made the music
decisions for the songs that are sung between skits, but I asked them to
seriously consider using Chris Rice's song "Big Enough." It's always been a
favorite.

Re: Some Hard Questions about God for Thanksgiving

spaghettipie — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 14:22:55 -0000

Definitely some hard questions in there, Marcus, and I'm thankful our God is big enough to handle them. Sometimes I sit back and look out our faith and think about how strange it really is. I mean, we have a "relationship" with someone we can't see, can't hear, can't touch, and we talk to him, sing to him, write about him. We have strange rituals (eating his body and drinking his blood?). And yet, I know that the hope I experience is tangible. His love is palpable. His peace really does transcend. . .I look forward to heaven when this life all makes more sense.

I've heard of that book and will have to add it to my wish list.